"What is market?"
"What is the trend?"
These two questions are heard frequently in Silicon Valley, but there is too often a dearth of local, original data to answer either one. For 10 years now, Silicon Valley technology law firm Fenwick & West has been addressing this need in the area of venture financings.
A hands-on team at the firm publishes an in-depth quarterly analysis known as the Venture Capital Survey. The latest "anniversary edition" was released a few weeks ago for the fourth quarter of 2011 and is available on Fenwick's web-site here.
I read this report every quarter for a few reasons. First, the amount of data analyzed by the survey is remarkable. In the most recent survey, 117 companies that reported raising money in the fourth quarter of 2011 were analyzed. The financings are examined not just for valuation but for some of the key provisions that were used, such as liquidation preferences and anti-dilution features.
Second, the results have a strong local flavor. The analysis covers Silicon Valley-headquartered companies, giving it a much more relevant feel for our ecosystem than national statistics.
Third, the work is unique and original. Much of the research on financing terms involves manual labor. About 10 Fenwick professionals are involved in putting the report together every quarter.
Finally, the authors draw many interesting conclusions that help put the mountains of data into useful context about trends. In the latest edition, the authors state that some industries, such as Internet/digital media and software, are concerned about a bubble, while others, such as cleantech and life science, are having a tougher time. Against this backdrop, the detailed tables reveal that in the fourth quarter 80% of the software industry financings were up rounds, but only 29% of the cleantech transactions were up rounds.
To join me in subscribing to Fenwick's Venture Capital Survey, click here.
Sunday, March 18, 2012
Saturday, January 14, 2012
When both the coffee and the fancy lobby become an afterthought
Last year I spoke at a GigaOM conference. I was a panelist on one of my favorite
topics, engaging independent contractors using legally compliant models. But, while at the conference, another
panel about co-working caught my ear.
One of the speakers was Don Ball,
co-founder of a successful co-working space in Minnesota. Co-working spaces are shared workspaces
where freelancers or even small startups can get a wifi connection, a few desks
(typically in a open, collaborative floor plan) and minor administrative
services in a reasonable, flexible fee arrangement. It is often thought of as the evolution of the typical corner coffee shop, with a bit more interaction among the customers. In other words, a
co-working space is the place to go when your day is less about the coffee and
more about productivity.
Ball and others in this particular panel were making the
point that larger companies will increasingly take advantage of the co-working
trend. Even Fortune 500 companies
can find ways to utilize co-working concepts. After all, the core idea is that a technology-enabled
contributor does not need to physically be in any one specific location to be
productive. So, by essentially
setting their employees free to “roam,” the large corporation can save millions
by reducing its significant real estate footprint while potentially reaping
other benefits, such as happier employees and a more geographically distributed
sales force.
Already, it’s predicted that more than 50% of the private workforce will be independent by the year 2020. These will be people utilizing new
places to work. Imagine adding to
that mix larger corporations that want to reap similar benefits.
It is entirely possible that we are witnessing the beginning
of the end of the fancy corporate office space.
Saturday, December 17, 2011
How to actually get to win-win
Many companies and business development executives talk
about the importance of a “win-win” philosophy in their relationships and
negotiations. They want to be
successful and their partners to be successful in a true synergy. But, what is their road map for getting
to a win-win? Too often, there
isn’t a real methodology behind the talk.
Win-win is in danger before the race even starts.
Here’s an approach that can be applied to many different
types of business arrangements to try to achieve that holy grail of
win-win. It has worked for me over
many years of negotiating hundreds of deals.
1. Spend extra time on the economics up front. Since win-win is supposed to mean that
each company makes more money with the partner than it would without, what
modeling has been done to ensure that this becomes reality? In practice, it is tempting to jump
into papering a transaction before serious financial analysis has truly run its
course. Yet, a dedication to
getting the numbers right will typically pay dividends.
2. Respect, rather than take advantage of, your partner’s largest concerns. This is harder than it sounds. Every negotiation will involve a certain amount of chess and horse-trading. But, if your partner reveals a walk away position or two that will be standard in its industry, respecting that position will instantly deepen the relationship.
3. When it comes to the legalese, be prepared to settle on true neutrality. The typical contract will favor the side of a deal that prepared it. There isn’t necessarily anything wrong with that, as long as both sides understand what true neutrality means and, assuming the leverage is roughly equal, are willing to settle on it. It means reciprocal representations, indemnifications and confidentiality provisions. When two companies are located in different states, it often means choosing a third state’s law to govern the contract.
4. Understand the details. Is the devil really in the details? Since execution is about details, the answer is almost always yes. Sure, contracts get amended all the time, but the wrong starting point could kill the relationship before it has time to blossom. Lawyers should understand the business purpose and the business people should understand the legalese. Everyone needs to read the contract.
5. Strive for a long-term contract. As much as corporate America talks about long-term thinking and strategy, there are many forces that make this challenging. Quarterly earnings calls for public companies emphasize 90 days of performance. Revenue recognition rules can essentially encourage short-term deals. It’s difficult to establish win-win in a short time frame. Aim for a five-year term. Expect, plan for and demand success. Commitment facilitates win-win.
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Ownership is (still) everything
With open source software being widely popular and Larry Lessig becoming a household name, is the concept of intellectual property ownership dead?
Absolutely not.
Inventors are still applying for patents as aggressively as ever. Ownership comes up in almost every commercial sales contract, in every M&A transaction and in every IPO. Today we even have companies claiming ownership in LinkedIn contacts.
This is all because ownership remains a great differentiator. Generally, ownership entitles you not just to engage in some kind of lucrative activity. It also allows you to prevent others from doing it. Companies sue others for patent infringement or negotiate for ownership of software in commercial contracts because millions, potentially billions, of dollars are at stake.
How should companies react to this reality?
Embrace it. Recognize this value and work to maximize it. Invent, develop and patent using the best engineering talent you can find. Once you have intellectual property, protect, nurture and grow it. Negotiate hard when the topic of intellectual property comes up, because revenue and enterprise value are up for grabs.
By acknowledging that ownership of intellectual property remains a foundational issue in company valuations, companies set the philosophical groundwork for business practices that will help them win.
Monday, October 24, 2011
The death of the simple NDA
Non-disclosure agreements may never have really been simple, but they do seem to have become more complex in recent years. No doubt part of the reason for this is the increasing sophistication of those writing and managing NDAs.
Whatever the cause, the result is a substantial amount of risk for companies and individuals who dismiss NDAs as mere "boilerplate." It is now as crucial as ever that those doing business with others use NDAs and, when using others' forms, read them carefully.
Here are a few challenging positions I have seen in NDAs that I suggest users approach with caution.
1. Assignment of intellectual property ownership. An NDA is designed to simply allow two parties to start talking to one another about a deeper relationship. Yet, in a couple cases, I have actually seen an NDA provide for one party's ownership of everything created over the course of the relationship. No proprietary technology company will sign up for this.
2. Non-competition provisions. Occasionally, NDAs will prevent one party from competing with the other. This is another aggressive position with economic implications far beyond the NDA's typical "Let's talk" premise. Non-competition provisions may also raise anti-trust issues.
3. No-hire provisions. Some NDAs will prohibit the solicitation of the other party's employees or customers. Others will take the next step of seeking an actual no-hire clause. Either provision will drive how the parties interact with one another.
4. Lack of an independent development carve-out. Most NDAs provide exceptions for what kind of information is deemed confidential. A crucial exception that is sometimes missing regards independent development. It's important to be able to retain the right to come up with good ideas independently of those that a vendor, customer, reseller or joint venture partner might have.
5. Inappropriate period of protection. NDAs will typically provide for a confidentiality period of about five years. But, a business providing access to its most sensitive secret sauce that it expects to be valuable for decades would certainly want more protection than that. It's important to think through how an NDA will be used in a given situation before signing up for a certain period of protection.
6. Venue provisions. Parties will often agree in advance where to litigate a dispute arising out of a contract. But, this choice of location could create leverage for one party over the other. Be thoughtful about agreeing to venue in your business partner's backyard if it's thousands of miles away from where you work.
7. Inconsistencies with other applicable documents. If some other commercial agreement is signed as a result of the initial discussions, it will be important to consider how it relates to the NDA. A new agreement with its own confidentiality provisions could create confusing conflicts with the NDA. The NDA needs to be either completely superseded or carefully integrated into the new agreement.
Whatever the cause, the result is a substantial amount of risk for companies and individuals who dismiss NDAs as mere "boilerplate." It is now as crucial as ever that those doing business with others use NDAs and, when using others' forms, read them carefully.
Here are a few challenging positions I have seen in NDAs that I suggest users approach with caution.
1. Assignment of intellectual property ownership. An NDA is designed to simply allow two parties to start talking to one another about a deeper relationship. Yet, in a couple cases, I have actually seen an NDA provide for one party's ownership of everything created over the course of the relationship. No proprietary technology company will sign up for this.
2. Non-competition provisions. Occasionally, NDAs will prevent one party from competing with the other. This is another aggressive position with economic implications far beyond the NDA's typical "Let's talk" premise. Non-competition provisions may also raise anti-trust issues.
3. No-hire provisions. Some NDAs will prohibit the solicitation of the other party's employees or customers. Others will take the next step of seeking an actual no-hire clause. Either provision will drive how the parties interact with one another.
4. Lack of an independent development carve-out. Most NDAs provide exceptions for what kind of information is deemed confidential. A crucial exception that is sometimes missing regards independent development. It's important to be able to retain the right to come up with good ideas independently of those that a vendor, customer, reseller or joint venture partner might have.
5. Inappropriate period of protection. NDAs will typically provide for a confidentiality period of about five years. But, a business providing access to its most sensitive secret sauce that it expects to be valuable for decades would certainly want more protection than that. It's important to think through how an NDA will be used in a given situation before signing up for a certain period of protection.
6. Venue provisions. Parties will often agree in advance where to litigate a dispute arising out of a contract. But, this choice of location could create leverage for one party over the other. Be thoughtful about agreeing to venue in your business partner's backyard if it's thousands of miles away from where you work.
7. Inconsistencies with other applicable documents. If some other commercial agreement is signed as a result of the initial discussions, it will be important to consider how it relates to the NDA. A new agreement with its own confidentiality provisions could create confusing conflicts with the NDA. The NDA needs to be either completely superseded or carefully integrated into the new agreement.
Monday, October 3, 2011
Insider PSA: "You're shady and self-dealing"
Venture investor Chamath Palihapitiya recently wrote a critical e-mail to the founder of Airbnb. Palihapitiya passed on the opportunity to invest in Airbnb's latest financing round. His criticism focused on a controversial and unusual element of the transaction. In a nutshell, a dividend to common stockholders was being used to provide cash to founders to the disadvantage of other employees. The e-mail raised many valid points and some good coaching, including the sentence, "Treat your employees the same as you'd treat yourself."
So what's the problem?
The problem is that the e-mail was somehow leaked to a reporter. Given the amount of confidential information Palihapitiya was given, this amounted to a credible insider public service announcement that the founder could be considered, as the e-mail put it, "shady and self-dealing." I don't believe that Palihapitiya intentionally leaked the e-mail, but the disclosure was embarrassing to all involved.
It's also symptomatic of a couple challenges in Silicon Valley's business culture.
We have become too reliant on e-mail to communicate in detail about sensitive topics. Coaching and constructive criticism are valuable, but e-mail is often an unhelpful channel for it.
In addition, Silicon Valley is sometimes too open. We have open office spaces. Many investors refuse to sign non-disclosure agreements. Some companies sign NDAs without reading or thinking about them - a very risky practice given that I have actually seen proposed "NDAs" in the last few years that assigned all intellectual property created in the business relationship to one party. Every thought is posted on Twitter. The "confidential" footnote is not inserted in the first place or ignored.
It's a good time to revisit the value of 1:1 verbal communication and confidentiality. Not everything is meant for public dissemination.
If Palihapitiya's email "really was just an attempt to give (the founder of Airbnb) private feedback," he should have picked up the phone.
So what's the problem?
The problem is that the e-mail was somehow leaked to a reporter. Given the amount of confidential information Palihapitiya was given, this amounted to a credible insider public service announcement that the founder could be considered, as the e-mail put it, "shady and self-dealing." I don't believe that Palihapitiya intentionally leaked the e-mail, but the disclosure was embarrassing to all involved.
It's also symptomatic of a couple challenges in Silicon Valley's business culture.
We have become too reliant on e-mail to communicate in detail about sensitive topics. Coaching and constructive criticism are valuable, but e-mail is often an unhelpful channel for it.
In addition, Silicon Valley is sometimes too open. We have open office spaces. Many investors refuse to sign non-disclosure agreements. Some companies sign NDAs without reading or thinking about them - a very risky practice given that I have actually seen proposed "NDAs" in the last few years that assigned all intellectual property created in the business relationship to one party. Every thought is posted on Twitter. The "confidential" footnote is not inserted in the first place or ignored.
It's a good time to revisit the value of 1:1 verbal communication and confidentiality. Not everything is meant for public dissemination.
If Palihapitiya's email "really was just an attempt to give (the founder of Airbnb) private feedback," he should have picked up the phone.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Customer Loyalty Chronicles, Vol. I – Roland
Hugely successful companies often boast about their "secret sauce." They will cite particular ways they manage or recruit their people, their unique methods of quality control or their brilliant Super Bowl advertisements. Successful companies surely have a secret sauce and the greatest companies rise above with long term customer loyalty.
When customers love the product so much that they are passionate about the company, that is an irreplaceable asset. Apple sets the bar for its ability to generate long term customer loyalty. But, there are other companies that have secured long term customer loyalty.
Roland Corporation is a company that I feel doesn't get near the attention it deserves for its success in this realm. The Japanese manufacturer of electronic musical instruments has been a market leader for over 35 years, supplies major artists as well as amateurs worldwide and has developed the most devoted following in the industry. In studying Roland, I have observed three elements that have driven its long term customer loyalty.
Innovation. Roland is obsessively innovative, in ways that might even lead some to at first question it. Apple is widely revered for being able to create demand with supply. When the iPod came out, many said, "Why do we need this exactly?" Today, everyone has one. Same for Roland's electronic drums. An oddity at first, today they are common because of their flexibility and reliability.
Passion. An extraordinarily driven and passionate founder seems to make a world of difference when it comes to customer focus. Roland's was Ikutaro Kakehashi, who was orphaned at age two, spent four years of his early life in a hospital with a protracted illness and started his career as a watch repairman. The love Mr. Kakehashi has for music and the desire he has to build the best musical instruments in the world is clear in his products and in his moving personal memoir. If you're interested in an off the beaten path business book, I highly recommend it. It's as if Mr. Kakehashi is still obsessed with making sure each and every customer who comes by his little store is delighted with his work.
Freshness. Roland is able to stay fresh with long time customers and gain new ones by keeping up with emerging trends in music recording and performance. Among the ways it does this is through promotion of its relationships with young stars, such as Lady Gaga. Decades after starting his company, Mr. Kakehashi remains a dreamer, writing in his book that Roland is looking at "turning imagination into sounds, images, and even shapes, then combining them to produce new solutions."
Long term customer loyalty is a key element of corporate success. Companies that are able to get there, like Roland Corporation, are great guides to achieving it.
When customers love the product so much that they are passionate about the company, that is an irreplaceable asset. Apple sets the bar for its ability to generate long term customer loyalty. But, there are other companies that have secured long term customer loyalty.
Roland Corporation is a company that I feel doesn't get near the attention it deserves for its success in this realm. The Japanese manufacturer of electronic musical instruments has been a market leader for over 35 years, supplies major artists as well as amateurs worldwide and has developed the most devoted following in the industry. In studying Roland, I have observed three elements that have driven its long term customer loyalty.
Innovation. Roland is obsessively innovative, in ways that might even lead some to at first question it. Apple is widely revered for being able to create demand with supply. When the iPod came out, many said, "Why do we need this exactly?" Today, everyone has one. Same for Roland's electronic drums. An oddity at first, today they are common because of their flexibility and reliability.
Passion. An extraordinarily driven and passionate founder seems to make a world of difference when it comes to customer focus. Roland's was Ikutaro Kakehashi, who was orphaned at age two, spent four years of his early life in a hospital with a protracted illness and started his career as a watch repairman. The love Mr. Kakehashi has for music and the desire he has to build the best musical instruments in the world is clear in his products and in his moving personal memoir. If you're interested in an off the beaten path business book, I highly recommend it. It's as if Mr. Kakehashi is still obsessed with making sure each and every customer who comes by his little store is delighted with his work.
Freshness. Roland is able to stay fresh with long time customers and gain new ones by keeping up with emerging trends in music recording and performance. Among the ways it does this is through promotion of its relationships with young stars, such as Lady Gaga. Decades after starting his company, Mr. Kakehashi remains a dreamer, writing in his book that Roland is looking at "turning imagination into sounds, images, and even shapes, then combining them to produce new solutions."
Long term customer loyalty is a key element of corporate success. Companies that are able to get there, like Roland Corporation, are great guides to achieving it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)